Thursday, June 19, 2014

Reflection

Here is another blog I found that touches on Securities Lending, and the risks involved:

http://www.etf.com/sections/blog/16166-sec-lending-risks-with-fewer-rewards.html

While the author does get a lot of information right, I don't think he fully understands how the securities lending process works, and the various tools available to both the lender and the borrower.

I work for the leading securities lending service provider, SunGard/Loanet, who has built a system that eliminates the majority of the risk mentioned in the above blog.  As the author points out, the two risks involved with securities lending are when the borrower defaults, or when the held collateral decreases in value.  His point is that when the borrower returns the securities they borrowed, the lender returns the collateral.  If the collateral decreased in value while the lender held them, are they now on the hook for the difference required to make the borrower whole?

Securities lending systems like the one I work with daily have processes that eliminate this risk altogether.  We have a system called "marking", where we analyze the daily price movements in both the security being borrowed/lent, and the corresponding collateral.  If the borrowed security increases in price, the borrower must supply additional collateral to the lender to make up this difference.  This ensures the lender always holds 100% + of the value of the securities they have lent out.  Also, if the lender is holding some form of security as the collateral, and that collateral decreases in price, the borrower must again supply additional collateral.  Each night we compare the value of the securities the borrower holds, and the value of the collateral the lender holds. Whenever there is a difference, one of the sides is "marked" so both sides are in agreement.

This eliminates the majority of the risk involved in securities lending.  If a borrower were to default on a loan, the lender would be holding the necessary collateral to then go and re-buy those securities in the market.  There are still slight risks involved despite the marking process, but it has greatly reduced the overall risk of securities lending. 

Overview

In today's market, owners of pools of securities are always looking for an extra way to boost earnings and make an extra buck.  Lending securities through an SLA agreement is a great way to do that.  Securities Lending involves a lender, typically a mutual fund, hedge fund, pension plan or some form of large pooled investments, lending out those securities to a borrower.  There are a number of reasons a borrower may need a security, but most commonly firms borrow securities to avoid a transaction failure, for financing purposes, or to facilitate selling a stock "short". 

Since a lender is giving up securities in the loan, they ask for an equal or greater amount back in collateral.  Typically a borrower will give cash as the collateral for the loan, which will be returned to them when they return the securities they borrowed. This helps protect against defaults, or the borrower being unable to return the shares.  A typical securities lending transaction would look like this:

Lender sends 100 shares of IBM to borrower with a value of $10,000.
Borrower sends $10,500 in cash to lender as collateral on the loan.
The "rebate" on the transaction is .5%

Lender invests the $10,500 in a short-term money market or other account that yields 2% annually.
Lender "rebates" a portion of the interest back to the borrower at an agreed upon rate, which as indicated above is .5%.  The lender's earnings would be the 1.5% difference. 

As you can see from this simple transaction, the borrower wins because they get the securities they need to process the transaction, while also earning a small rebate on the cash they provided as collateral.  The lender wins as well because they loan out securities they are not using and invest the cash they get to earn interest.

Securities lending can get a lot more complex than this, but it is still a great way for holders of pooled investments to boost their portfolio's earnings.